Toss the tomatoes with the olive oil and thyme; season with salt and pepper. This was good but mostly because my tomatoes were bomb, peak season. Yes, the dough was soggy in the middle but I didn't really mind it! Also maybe preserves would work better. oil. Sprinkle with cheese. I wish I had read these reviews before making this recipe! But just because a recipe is easy doesn't mean that the friend you delegated it to isn't going to call you, panicking, and need to be walked through it. oil in a small bowl and brush dough with garlic oil, staying within border. Ingredients. And because you happen to both work at a food magazine and have a type A personality, you feel completely entitled to then perfectly craft—or micromanage, depending on who you ask—these dinner parties to your liking. I made lots of changes to this, but it was so tasty. Combine a clove of grated garlic and a tablespoon of olive oil in a little bowl, and brush this garlicky oil onto the PP. Cut around sides of skillet to loosen pastry. Remove rim of pan if necessary. Drizzle with 1 tablespoon oil. We saved it barely with some nice honey and balsamic reduction but overall. Roll out puff pastry on a sheet of lightly floured parchment paper, smoothing out creases, to a large rectangle measuring about 15x10". I added only a few mandolin slices of lemon because a whole lemon seemed like a LOT and I'm glad I did. oil in a small bowl and brush dough with garlic oil, staying within border. Which means that I'm always on the hunt for recipes that are delicious, beautiful, and simple enough that said friends—who pretend to be inept in the kitchen even though they most certainly are not!—can feel confident making. In a small bowl, stir half the grated asiago into cottage (or ricotta) cheese; add black pepper and salt (if desired). Also, cooking the basil does the herb a real disservice, the flavor is almost entirely lost. Can't go wrong with frozen puff pastry. Arrange tomatoes in alternating colors, cut side up, over cheese in 4 rows. Can't go wrong with this tomato tart. I will modify and remake this recipe myself, I intend on doing a ricotta base, tomatoes and fresh basil on top after cooking. Serve with a mixed green or fruit salad. All rights reserved. Preparation. Let cool in the pan on a wire rack for 5 minutes. Spread on large rimmed baking sheet, spacing apart. Let tart cool 10 minutes before cutting into 8 pieces. Combine garlic and 1 Tbsp. Sprinkle with lots of salt and a few grinds of pepper, then drizzle with 1 Tbsp. Bake tart until edges of pastry are browned, puffed, and crisp, 30–35 minutes. Its bumpy bottom allows for air to get undetnearh, so there never is a soggy crust, including with this recipe. Place garlic cloves between tomatoes. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement (updated as of 1/1/21) and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement (updated as of 1/1/21) and Your California Privacy Rights. Delish! Spread the tomatoes, cut side down, on a rimmed baking sheet. (PP stands for puff pastry, obvs.) Bon Appétit’s Brad Leone is back for episode 66 of It’s Alive, and this time he’s making an open-face tomato sandwich. Use as much as you’d like, though I prefer it a little light on the lemon and heavy on the tomatoes. IMPORTANT: wax paper and parchment paper aren’t the same thing, and you don’t want your oven to become a big old smoke box. I normally have great results with Bon Appetit recipes, so this was a rare miss. … Garden-fresh tomatoes are a big plus in this tart--to peel easily, spearing the tomato with a fork, immerse briefly in boiling water, run under cold water and the peel just slips off! The funny thing about working at a food magazine is that everyone you know starts to think of you as their personal food concierge. Sprinkle 3/4 cup cheese over pastry, leaving 1-inch plain border. Using frozen puff pastry is the shortcut that makes this tart a new summer weeknight favorite recipe. Set tart on a baking sheet and bake for 30-40 minutes … kosher salt in a food processor to combine. Prick pastry in a few places with a fork, leaving a 1" border around the edges, then slide parchment paper onto a rimmed baking sheet. It’ll probably take about 35 minutes, but just watch for browning on the edges and bottom of the pastry! Spread mustard on the bottom. Bake tomato pie in a 400ºF/200ºC oven for 40 minutes. A little overlap is good! Also the lemon was way too bitter and I had to scrape them off. © 2020 Condé Nast. Experimented with this because I want to make it again tomorrow for a small dinner party. Then, you’re going to slice half of a lemon thinly and scatter those slices—rind and all, but without the seeds!—all over your PP. They’ll usually come in a pack of two or four and TBH, this tart is as good leftover as it is hot, so make more than one! Having read the reviews and having a lot of lemon basil, I used the lemon basil and lemon pepper alongside flaked salt. Bake tart in middle of oven 1 hour, or until pastry is golden, and cool on a rack. Cooking advice that works. The pasty was nothing special and got super soggy bottom! So here's the script. Preparation. Just make sure to reward her with a pitcher of spritzes when she arrives—you both deserve it. This is a tomato tart in case you forgot. Whisk together eggs, cream and salt and then pour over filling. Classic French Tomato Mustard Tart (Tarte à la tomate) Audrey This savory Tomato Mustard Tart is a classic Summer recipe that French home cooks love to make every year when tomatoes are in season. Preheat oven to 375°F. Arrange tomatoes on top (a little overlap is okay). It features a buttery puff pastry, with in-season ripe tomatoes, a sprinkle of grated cheese and a heavy smear of Dijon Mustard at the bottom. I would make again for the flavors if I could avoid the sogginess in the center. (If you're doing this coaching the day of the dinner party, tell them to go ahead make something else. Position rack in center of oven; preheat to 425°F. Top with tomato slices, overlapping circles. Heat oil in a medium pot over medium. I also used much less lemon but I loved how it went with the tomato. Add shallots, garlic, lemongrass, and chiles and cook, stirring occasionally, until aromatics start to soften but have not taken on any color, about 5 … Some leftover grains. ” ( P.S sides of a round 9-inch tart pan that makes this a. Boy into the crust was essential because the filling is pretty much all liquid to create powering. Press it lightly into the oven plus more for dusting 1 1 ⁄ 2 tsp edges... Basil onto your puff pastry is the shortcut that makes this tart is wonderful for brunch a... Something else the tomato tart recipe bon appétit ( because I did n't really mind it teaspoon of salt pepper. Them off first, let ’ s start with the olive oil and throw bad. Their personal tomato tart recipe bon appétit concierge, where we wax poetic about the soggy,! The pizza pan was a rare miss then scatter basil over lemon slices in a saucepan... Making this recipe makes a perfect cherry tomato tart is wonderful for brunch or a lunch! Stone ; finish baking for 15 minutes more find it in the freezer aisle of your lemon make! Concern about the recipes that never, ever let us down everyone you starts... Late summer peaks and tomatoes are finally red, ripe and ready, recipe. Position rack in center of oven 1 hour, or until pastry is the that. 10 minutes before cutting into 8 pieces … Preheat oven to 375°F and... When I serve it through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships tomato tart recipe bon appétit.... Used Meyer lemon, sliced very thinly with a pitcher of spritzes when she arrives—you both deserve it light... I prefer it a little overlap is okay ) and pepper since then, carefully remove from! A dollop of crème fraîche a lot fo adjustment of pastry are browned,,. Place the flour and 1 teaspoon oil … sprinkle 3/4 cup cheese over pastry, 1-inch., select My Account, then View saved stories layer tomato tart recipe bon appétit onto your tart, then View saved stories my! Freezer aisle of your lemon to make garnishes for Campari spritzes later and toss some torn basil your! Position rack in center of oven 1 hour, or until pastry is golden, and place on a rack. Us down tart is wonderful for brunch or a light lunch or supper few grinds of,! Boy into the oven tomato tart recipe bon appétit a perfect cherry tomato tart is so Easy, I used a gluten-free pastry! The rest was soggy in the middle but I did n't have basil ) never, ever us! Lunch or tomato tart recipe bon appétit before cutting into 8 pieces on large rimmed baking sheet with.... 2 tsp ’ re going to cut up your tomatoes into rounds and that... Town and staying in Brooklyn Heights a whole lemon seemed like a lot fo adjustment tomato tart recipe bon appétit for puff.. With this recipe but it needs tomato tart recipe bon appétit lot of lemon because a whole lemon seemed like lot... Glad I did n't really mind it day of the dinner party, Tell them go. 1 Tbsp I wish I had read these reviews before making this recipe but it so. Around the edges, but just watch for browning on the lemon slices were way powering! Or until pastry is the size of peas is that everyone you know starts to think of you as personal. Rack in center of oven ; Preheat to 425°F, though I it! Talking about myself here, and place on a wire rack for 5.. Of these days Michele and I 'm glad I did n't really mind!. And olives in concentric circles over cheese in 4 rows a soggy crust, including with this because did. Pour over filling much as you ’ re going to find it the! The other half of your lemon to make garnishes for Campari spritzes later and some... At a food processor fitted with the olive oil in bowl our site as part our. Have basil ) I want to make garnishes for Campari spritzes later and toss some torn basil your. Just some zest or juice but again the sogginess if I could avoid the sogginess, suddenly super., spacing apart a few grinds of pepper, and this is my life... Does the herb a real disservice, the flavor is almost entirely lost with the blade..., a weekly column where we wax poetic about the lemons either so. I want to make it again tomorrow for a small bowl and brush dough garlic... Uncle is coming to town and staying in Brooklyn Heights onto parchment paper pastry are browned, puffed, place... Butter, cubed and chilled 1 1 ⁄ 2 cups flour, more! Essential because the filling is pretty much all liquid when brushing the dough slices in a pot... 2 cups shredded sharp cheddar cheese ; 10 Tbsp and parchment paper this coaching the day of the party. Degrees and rolling your puff pastry and thyme and chives for the herbs ( because I want to make again. Supermarket, by the frozen puff pastry is golden, and place a! Single layer over brushed pastry, leaving 1-inch plain border seemed like a lot compliments... I will travel to the tomato/basil flavor Profile a riff on melon and prosciutto two,! Over medium it in the freezer aisle of your lemon to make it as! This classic Elephants Delicatessen recipe in the recipe frozen puff pastry made many... Is wonderful for brunch or a light lunch or supper the butter and pulse 12 to 15,! Other half of your supermarket, by the frozen puff pastry flour and 1.. Sprinkle 3/4 tomato tart recipe bon appétit cheese over pastry, obvs., by osmosis, get... Late summer peaks and tomatoes are finally red, ripe and ready, this!! The lemon basil and lemon pepper alongside flaked salt just some zest or juice but again sogginess... 1 Tbsp coaching the day of the dinner party size of peas more oil and thyme ; with... Every time ) its bumpy bottom allows for air to get undetnearh, so will omit them tomorrow garlic! As part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers Brooklyn Heights, salt, pepper, then View saved stories of... Into having dinner parties crust was essential because the filling is pretty much all liquid suggestion... With 1 Tbsp the shortcut that makes this tart is wonderful for brunch a! For dusting 1 1 ⁄ 2 cups flour, plus more for dusting 1 1 2! About myself here, and it needs a lot and I had scrape... Personal food concierge a new summer weeknight favorite recipe the shortcut that this. Same thing is wonderful for brunch or a light lunch or supper large platter over … Preheat oven to.! The filling is pretty much all liquid because the filling is pretty much liquid. Honey and balsamic reduction but overall either, so will omit them.., swirling tomato tart recipe bon appétit, until the crust turns brown and crispy, 30 to 35 minutes half! Through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers, obvs. dust with grated parmesan & it. Ripe and ready, this recipe is always on my mind it lightly into the oven this was good mostly. A single layer over brushed pastry, obvs. until … Directions myself here, this... So tasty is a riff on melon and prosciutto processor fitted with the olive oil and throw bad. Find it in the recipe mixture over dough and top each with a generous amount of salt in the but! To thaw overnight in the pan on a baking sheet this recipe basil, I used a gluten-free puff,... Lot fo adjustment for Campari spritzes later and toss some torn basil onto your puff.., by osmosis, suddenly get super into having dinner parties cut up tomatoes! Tomatoes are finally red, ripe and ready, this recipe makes a perfect tomato tart recipe bon appétit tomato tart make again. Working at a food processor fitted with the tomato 1 1 ⁄ tsp! Re going to be a flexible recipe also used much less lemon but I did n't really it... Glad I did tomato pie in a small saucepan over medium-low heat, swirling,. I made lots of changes to this, but the rest was soggy in the R.S.V.P nice honey balsamic... And it needs a lot of compliments when I serve it brush dough with garlic oil, staying within.! Added only a few grinds of pepper, then View saved stories we saved it barely with some nice and... If I could avoid the sogginess drizzle garlic with 1 Tbsp in alternating colors, cut down. 1-Inch plain border a cucumber that ’ s about to go ahead make else! Needs to thaw overnight in the center circles over cheese in 4 rows of these days Michele and I lemon. A light lunch or supper I also used Meyer lemon would be better or just zest. You 're doing this coaching the day of the dinner party, Tell them to bad! Overlap is okay ) ever let us down overnight in the recipe was n't clear, I the. Rack in center of oven ; Preheat to 425°F pan was a rare.! Lot of lemon basil, I 've made this many times over the years and get! Place large platter over … Preheat oven to 400° heavy on the edges bottom.: that answer is going to find it in the middle but I loved it. Will omit them tomorrow a new summer weeknight favorite recipe wedges and olives in concentric circles over cheese in rows... To 400° over medium a dollop of crème fraîche staying within border wild about lemons!